Materials for your 3D print

Yannic Fréson 3D, a 3D printing service for the Heist-op-den-Berg area in Belgium, prints in three plastics: PLA in matte, silk and wood-filled, PETG and ASA. PLA comes in many colours and suits most indoor prints. PETG is tougher and copes with moisture, ASA with heat, sun and rain. Those two are ordered on request.

Close-up of a planter: the rough ivory rim above its mandarin and terracotta bands

The materials side by side

Yannic Fréson 3D prints in PLA, PETG and ASA. PLA gives the cleanest surface and the most colours, but softens with heat. PETG is tougher and copes with moisture. ASA takes the most heat: the manufacturer states 100 °C, and it also withstands sun and rain.

Comparison of the filaments Yannic Fréson 3D prints with: appearance, strengths, weaknesses, use and colours
MaterialAppearanceGood atWeak atTypical forColours
Matte PLAMatte, layers hardly showCrisp detail, many colours, lowest priceHeat, sun, sustained loadDecoration, name signs, holders, indoor enclosuresA wide range
Silk PLASilky sheen, almost metallicA striking surfaceHeat; the sheen shows every imperfectionVases, ornaments, trophiesSheens such as Titan Gray and Gold
Wood-filled PLAMatte and grainy, with real wood powderA warm look; layers read as grainHeat, moisture, fine detailLamp bases, interior pieces, giftsWood shades such as walnut and rosewood
PETGMatteTough, copes with moisture and more heat than PLALess crisp detail, fine stringsClips, knobs, parts in daily useTo order, in the colour you need
ASAMatte to satinSun, rain and heat (100 °C according to the manufacturer)Shrinkage on large parts, higher priceAnything that stays outdoorsTo order, in the colour you need

The temperature for ASA is the heat deflection temperature (HDT at 0.45 MPa) that Bambu Lab states for its own filament on the Bambu ASA product page. It is the manufacturer's figure, measured on test bars, and not a guarantee for your part. A printed part with thin walls deforms sooner. For PLA and PETG no numbers are given here, on purpose.

PLA in three finishes

The same material, three characters. They can be combined in one object.

  • Matte PLA

    The workhorse finish, in most colours. The matte surface scatters the light, so the layers hardly show. Good for almost everything, which also makes it the dullest to write about.

  • Silk PLA

    A silky sheen that leans towards metal, in shades such as Titan Gray, Rose Gold and Gold. Lovely on flowing shapes such as vases. The sheen is honest: every imperfection in the design gets lit up too.

  • Wood-filled PLA

    PLA with real wood powder, in wood shades such as Black Walnut and Rosewood. The surface is matte and slightly grainy, and the layers read as grain. According to the manufacturer the shade can vary slightly from spool to spool.

PLA: the standard material

PLA is the standard material at Yannic Fréson 3D, for prints that stay indoors, have to look good and face no heat or heavy load. It gives a clean surface with crisp detail and comes in many colours and finishes: matte, silk, wood-filled, metallic and galaxy. PLA is not heat-resistant: in a car, a dishwasher or behind glass in the sun, a part can deform.

PLA stands for polylactic acid, a thermoplastic based on lactic acid. It is the most widely used filament in FDM printing because it melts at a low temperature and barely shrinks. For a print, what matters is this: PLA is stiff and dimensionally stable, it is the material in which fine detail and sharp colour boundaries come out best, and it is the cheapest filament in the rates. It is also rather brittle: it breaks before it bends.

It suits decorative and lightly functional prints indoors: name signs, keychains, planters, lamps, storage boxes, holders, scale models and enclosures for low-voltage electronics. Prototypes to judge shape and fit are usually printed in PLA too.

Wood-filled PLA remains a plastic that looks like wood: you cannot stain or plane it, and it is not suited to very fine detail. That the filament contains wood powder and that the colour can vary slightly per batch is stated on the Bambu Lab PLA Wood product page. Horizontal grooves or ribs in the design strengthen the wood effect, as on the base of the Valley Lamp.

Detail of the glowing sheets above the rim of the wood-filament base

PETG: for parts that have a job to do

Yannic Fréson 3D recommends PETG for parts that are used rather than looked at: knobs, clips, cable guides, hooks, wall holders and enclosures for electronics. PETG is tough: a part bends before it breaks, which suits clips and snap fits. It copes with moisture and with more heat than PLA.

PETG is a variant of PET, the plastic of drinks bottles, with glycol added so that the material stays tough and prints well. Descending from bottle plastic does not make a print suitable for food: the layers hold residue and the filament has no food-contact certificate.

The price of that toughness is a less tidy surface, sometimes with fine strings, and less crisp detail. Layers and seams show more than on matte PLA. For a decorative piece with sharp areas of colour, PLA remains the better-looking choice. For years in full sun, ASA is the better one.

Bambu Lab recommends an enclosed printer for PETG, so that a cold room does not weaken the bond between layers. That is stated in the Bambu Lab filament guide. The P1S is such an enclosed printer. Two of the price examples are worked out in PETG: a knob for an appliance, from your own file, and a batch of fifty clips.

ASA: for outdoors and for heat

Yannic Fréson 3D recommends ASA for parts that stay outdoors: caps and clips for garden furniture, wall holders, covers for a caravan, bicycle or motorcycle. ASA is also for indoor parts that get warm, such as a holder in a car. According to the filament manufacturer, ASA has a heat deflection temperature of 100 °C.

ASA (acrylonitrile styrene acrylate) is a hard plastic developed for better weather resistance: it withstands UV light, oxidation and ageing. The figures come from the Bambu Lab ASA product page. Yannic Fréson 3D does not print ABS; ASA does that job and copes with the sun as well.

The downside is shrinkage. Large, flat parts can warp or split between the layers, so ASA mainly suits smaller, compact parts. It needs a warm print chamber, which the enclosed P1S provides.

An enclosure in ASA is meant for low-voltage electronics. For mains voltage, for parts right up against a heating element and for anything somebody's safety depends on, nothing is printed, in any material. ASA has the highest rate per gram, which covers the filament itself and the greater risk of a failed print. If you have no heat and no sun, you do not need it and would only be paying more.

Which material to choose

At Yannic Fréson 3D the choice of material follows from three questions: does the part stay indoors or outdoors, does it get warm, and does it have to bend without breaking. Indoors and without load, PLA is enough. For parts in use, PETG is the first choice. For outdoors or for heat, it becomes ASA.

You do not have to make the choice yourself. Write in your request what the part is for and where it will end up; the recommended material is then in your quote. The most common mistake is choosing PLA for something that lives in a car. The second is choosing ASA for something that sits on a bookshelf.

The full comparison, with a table per property, is in the guide PLA vs PETG vs ASA: which material should you pick?.

What ordering on request means

At Yannic Fréson 3D, PETG and ASA are bought for each job: the filament is ordered as soon as you approve the quote, in the colour of your choice. The lead time of 3 to 5 working days can become longer as a result; the date your part will be ready is in the quote.

The advantage is that you choose the colour freely. The drawback is that a small part in an unusual colour has to wait for a spool. If you are in a hurry and the colour does not matter, say so: then the spool that arrives soonest is ordered.

What no material here does

Yannic Fréson 3D does not print resin, metal, SLS nylon or flexible materials such as TPU. None of the three plastics comes with a food-contact certificate, and no print is sold as a toy for young children or with a guaranteed load rating. The largest part in one piece is 256 × 256 × 256 mm.

Food contact
No certificate. Not suitable for contact with food.
Children
Prints are decorative or functional objects, not toys.
Load
No guarantee on the weight a part can carry.
Flexible material
No TPU or rubber-like filaments.
Transparent
No glass-clear parts; FDM layers scatter the light.
Other technologies
No resin, metal or SLS nylon.

Don't know which material you need?

Describe what the part is for and where it will live. The recommended material is in your quote, with the reason.